In Defense of Public Language
نویسنده
چکیده
notion of 'common, public language' that remains mysterious...useless for any form of theoretical explanation....There is simply no way of making sense of this prong of the externalist theory of meaning and language, as far as I can see, or of any of the work in theory of meaning and philosophy of language that relies on such notions, a statement that is intended to cut rather a large swath. (Chomsky 1995, pp. 48-9) It is a striking fact that despite the constant reliance on some notion of 'community language' or 'abstract language,' there is virtually no attempt to explain what it might be. (Chomsky 1993, p. 39) ....either we must deprive the notion communication of all significance, or else we must reject the view that the purpose of language is communication. ...It is difficult to say what 'the purpose' of language is, except, perhaps, the expression of thought, a rather empty formulation. The functions of language are various. (Chomsky 1980, p. 230) I have yet to see a formulation that makes any sense of the position that "the essence of language is communication." (Chomsky 1980, p. 80; see also 1992b, p 215) At frequent intervals over the years, Professor Chomsky has inveighed against both common sense and technical notions of public language or "externalized language," claiming that they are confused, ill-defined, or of no scientific interest. As a scientist, he would be interested in public language only if it were a "real object of the real world"(Chomsky 1993:39) rather than an "artifactual" and "arbitrary" notion (Chomsky 1985:26). I propose to articulate such a notion of public language for him. Chomsky has also denounced the notion that the purpose of language is communication. I will argue, on the contrary, that a primary function of the human language faculty is to support linguistic conventions, and that these have an essentially communicative function. Despite this bold display of sounded disagreements with Chomsky, however, I agree with his objections to common views of public language completely: People who live near the Dutch border can communicate quite well with people living on the German side, but they speak different languages in accordance with the sense of the term Dummett argues is 'fundamental'..... (1992a, p. 101) Public language is a sprawling mass of crisscrossing, overlapping conventions, some known to some people, others to others. It does not divide into discrete portions, German versus Dutch versus French. What …
منابع مشابه
Educational needs of disaster management committee members in Iranian public hospitals covered by medical universities for passive defense
ABSTRACT BACKGROUND AND OBJECTIVE: Managers and experts training is one of the areas of creation and development infrastructure of passive defense in health system organizations including hospitals. This study was conducted to assess the educational needs of disaster management committee members in Iranian public hospitals for passive defense. METHODS: This cross-sectional study was conducted i...
متن کاملInvestigating Foreign Language Enjoyment and Public Speaking Class Anxiety in the EFL Class: A Mixed Methods Study
Foreign language enjoyment and speaking anxiety in the classroom are two potential emotion-inducing factors for foreign language learning. This sequential mixed methods study investigated whether and to what extent Iranian EFL students experienced foreign language enjoyment and public speaking anxiety in their English classrooms, and how they characterize the sources of the enjoyment and speaki...
متن کاملPublic Expenditure and Economic Growth in Nigeria (A Granger Causality Approach) 1983-2012
This paper examines the impact of government expenditure on the Nigerian economy for the period 1983 - 2012. The government expenditure components used as the explanatory variables in the model are: expenditures on Health, Education, Defense, Agriculture and Transportation and Communication. The Gross Domestic Product (GDP) was used as a parameter for measuring economic growth. In order to esta...
متن کاملPublic Schools and Private Language Institutes: Any Differences in Students’ L2 Motivational Self System?
To enrich our understanding of the attitudinal/motivational basis of foreign language learning at junior high school level, this study investigated the students’ status of L2 motivation, the relationship between motivational factors, and the possibility of predicting their motivated learning behavior in light of Dörnyei’s (2005, 2009) theory of L2 Motivational Self System. To this end, 1462 jun...
متن کاملAchieving the Optimal Share of Government Expenditures in GDP with the Aim of Maximizing Social Welfare (with Emphasis on the Affairs and Chapters of the Government's Public Budget)
Introduction: Increasing the level of social welfare with access the poor to order and security, education and health services, social security, increase the capacity of the economy in the chapters of agriculture, water and electricity, industries and mines, business, energy, transportation, information technology is possible. Meanwhile, the extent of government presence in how public policies ...
متن کاملAchieving the Optimal Share of Government Expenditures in GDP with the Aim of Maximizing Social Welfare (with Emphasis on the Affairs and Chapters of the Government's Public Budget)
Introduction: Increasing the level of social welfare with access the poor to order and security, education and health services, social security, increase the capacity of the economy in the chapters of agriculture, water and electricity, industries and mines, business, energy, transportation, information technology is possible. Meanwhile, the extent of government presence in how public policies ...
متن کاملذخیره در منابع من
با ذخیره ی این منبع در منابع من، دسترسی به آن را برای استفاده های بعدی آسان تر کنید
عنوان ژورنال:
دوره شماره
صفحات -
تاریخ انتشار 2000